Wednesday, February 2, 2011

BLOG #3 : The Dumbest Generation?

While I was reading "The Dumbest Generation? Don't Be Dumb" I felt it was a slap in the face. Here, someone was calling me stupid to my face and you know what, I deserved it. When I came across the sentence "Two thirds of high-school seniors in 2006 couldn't explain an old photo of a sign over a theater door reading COLORED ENTRANCE"I laughed and thought to myself, I know what that means and I then thought how stupid people are these days. 
A "colored entrance" at a downtown store.
Then I continued to think that the rest of the article is not going to apply to me and basically be a waste of my time if I continue to read, yet I proceeded. I am honestly not sure if reading on was a good thing or a bad thing. A little bit down the page I had a hard time getting past the sentence “The world's most heavily defended border? Mexico's with the United States, according to 30 percent of the same age group”. One second ago I was laughing at the fact that people could not answer what the term “colored entrance” meant and now people are probably laughing at me because I thought the world’s most heavily defended border was Mexico and the United States. It is embarrassing. I do not know who to blame. Do I blame myself for not knowing that or do I blame my teachers for not teaching it to me? I guess I feel it is neither one of our faults. Teachers have so many particulars, figures and concepts they have to teach that maybe simple facts of knowledge are forgotten about or maybe people just do not consider them “important” anymore. Everything else is being modernized these days, so maybe what we learn should only be about modern day material. By reading "The Dumbest Generation? Don't Be Dumb" I learned that I should not judge and laugh at people when they do not know something that I would consider common knowledge because they could just as well be laughing right back at me. I also learned that maybe I should think about the broader facts when I am learning a new concept instead of focusing on the elaborate details. I definitely will rethink the way I act when someone does not know an answer from this day forward.
A sign on the Mexico, United States border.

In regards to Mark Bauerlein’s comment about my generation being the dumbest generation, I would have to say that I disagree with him. I do acknowledge that our generation lacks what older generations would consider “common knowledge” but in defense to my generation, doesn’t every generation think that the younger generation is not as intelligent? I feel that Bauerlein’s comment was too generalized. We know a lot more about specific areas than previous generations.  In college we specialize in particular subjects so when we get to the point in our lives where Bauerlein is, we will be curing cancer, making more energy efficient vehicles and improving the world one step at a time. Bauerlein is entitled to his own opinion; however he needs to give us credit to what we do know. When Bauerlein said that people should not trust anyone under thirty, it struck a chord with me. I was so frustrated with his statement that I looked up the top 30 most influential people under the age of 30. I found it comforting knowing that people who are classified within the dumbest generation are considered to be influential people. 

Mark Zuckerberg; CEO and founder of Facebook.




 

5 comments:

  1. My boyfriend and I just watched "The Social Network" last night about Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook. You're right, he was definitely extremely intelligent and motivated. It's just interesting to think about how the extremely intelligent people of this generation are creating a social networking website, while the intelligent of generations before built spaceships, figured out the key to electricity, etc. They all kind of focus on new "technology" in their own way. I agree with your comments about not thinking you were one of the "dumb" people Mark Bauerlein was talking about, too. I didn't think I was either until I read the article. Of course none of us are going to think WE are dumb.. But he definitely makes some valid points. Like you pointed out though, we may be "dumb" in some ways but we're smarter than most in others. It's all relative.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree when you say that Bauerlein is viewing is as "dumb" because we are focusing more on one area than the others. It is good to have a general knowledge of everything, but in today's society, is just a general knowledge enough for us to get by? For every profession, there is some sort of specialization to go along with it which makes us experts in the area. The most successful people today are not the ones who have a general knowledge about everything. They are the ones who are experts in their area of concentration because they worked so hard to achieve it. I agree when you say that our generation should get credit for all the hard work, because we are ultimately the ones solving problems that previous generations caused.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also just viewed the Social Network. I think the irony of the movie (and Zuckerberg's situation) is that he's admittedly socially inept, yet he's responsible for creating the largest "social" network in the entire world...

    ReplyDelete
  4. I do agree with you but at the same time I am conflicted with my response. At the same time I do not agree that we are the Dumbest Generation. I mean think about it? Where is this world going... More Technology. We are being taught throughout our college career to use newer Technology. For what purpose? To get an edge on other countries and even our competitors in our majors. Like I have taken two GIS classes in my major because, that is what companies are looking for. They want those who are the most technologically savvy over someone who may be smart but, have no idea how to apply the software.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Your last statement really struck me about how some of the most influential people are under 30. I have great role models that are under the age of 30 and I also question Bauerlein's statement of trusting no one under that age. I also agree that we judge those younger than us and peple older, judge us, it's a never ending cycle of judgement and we act like we can stop it? No. This type of conversation just "urks" me because every single person in this worls has their own opinion but in the end, they're more thna likely hypocritical and do what they say is wrong.

    Also, just like I said in one of the other girl's blogs...we focus on one thing we are interested in to help another who isnt so interested. So in regards to Bauerlein, thank you for your insights and opinions but I'm sure one of us would be more than happy to prove him wrong and that's when I would love to see a book titled "The Dumbest Generation...Isn't As Dumb As I Thought".

    ReplyDelete